Key Takeaways
- The IRS cannot take money you need for basic living expenses if doing so creates economic hardship
- You have the right to force the IRS to consider your actual financial reality
- There are legal resolutions that can stop collections, even if the debt never gets fully paid
- These options aren’t available if you aren’t fully compliant with current filing and payment requirements
When you have tax debt to pay off, it can feel like you’re being forced to choose between satisfying the IRS and keeping the lights on.
But what a lot of taxpayers don’t know is that you actually have a legal right to a resolution that respects your financial reality.
So, take a deep breath. The IRS can’t collect in a way that leaves you unable to meet basic living expenses, thanks to the Right to a Fair and Just Tax System.
Does the IRS have to consider your circumstances?
Yes, the IRS is legally required to consider your facts and circumstances before enforcing collection.
That’s because of Taxpayer Right #10, the Right to a Fair and Just Tax System.
Economic hardship is defined very specifically: if IRS collection activity would prevent you from meeting basic living expenses, collection action must stop.
The challenge is that the IRS defaults to National and Local Standards to estimate what your life should cost, not what it actually costs.
That’s where expert representation matters.
As your resolution specialist, I can translate your real-world finances into the IRS’s legal framework. And I’ll challenge the IRS when their assumptions don’t match your reality.
Taxpayer Right #10 requires the IRS to evaluate three core areas:
- Is the tax actually owed, or was it assessed incorrectly?
- What is your ability to pay, based on assets and future income?
- Did IRS delays or errors unnecessarily increase your balance?
When these issues are raised properly, your case can move out of automated collections and into human review. Which is where negotiation becomes possible.
How does the IRS decide what you can pay?
Before any meaningful negotiation, the IRS calculates your Reasonable Collection Potential (RCP):
RCP = Net Equity in Assets + (Future Income × Multiplier)
Now, a few things are important to note here.
First, your assets aren’t valued at fair market value. Under IRS policy, assets are discounted to 80% Quick Sale Value. Because they get that you shouldn’t be forced to liquidate your property under ideal conditions just to satisfy a tax bill.
Also, your future income isn’t calculated indefinitely. Depending on your resolution path, the IRS looks at 12 or 24 months of disposable income (which is the multiplier). Not a lifetime projection.
Once your RCP is established, you’ll likely be facing one of these outcomes:
- Currently Not Collectible Status. If your income only covers allowed living expenses, the IRS must suspend collection. The debt remains, but levies and aggressive enforcement stop.
- Partial Payment Installment Agreement (PPIA). If you can pay something (but not the full balance before the 10 years are up) the IRS can be required to accept reduced payments until the Collection Statute Expiration Date. After that, the remaining balance is extinguished. If you’re close to your 10-year expiration date, this is a massive win because your debt eventually just disappears.
- The Six-Year Rule. If your balance can be resolved within 72 months, the IRS often allows actual expenses instead of rigid national standards (including higher housing or vehicle costs when justified). This is the sweet spot if you have higher-than-average living expenses and don’t want to lose your lifestyle to the National Standards.
- Offer in Compromise. The IRS allows compromise when full collection would be inequitable or create hardship, even if assets technically exist.
- Interest Abatement. Interest caused by IRS processing delays or errors can sometimes be removed through transcript analysis and formal requests.
How I fight for you
The IRS’s Allowable Living Expense (ALE) standards are averages. A lot of times, they lag inflation and ignore regional realities. The law does allow deviations… but only if they are documented and argued correctly.
Which is where you need an experienced representative on your side. We can look at things like your…
- Housing and utilities. Actual rent or mortgage costs can be treated as necessary when they support family stability, even if they exceed IRS caps.
- Healthcare. Because flat allowances rarely reflect chronic conditions or prescription costs. Proper medical documentation supports adjustments.
- Transportation. When your vehicle is required for income production or medical necessity, actual operating costs can be protected.
Final thoughts
The thing is, the IRS won’t listen to your hardship argument if you’re not compliant with your tax filings and estimated payments. They’re not keen on settling old debt if you’re still creating new debt.
So, if you’re concerned about not being able to pay what you owe, the first step is to get current on your tax filings.
Let’s get you caught up, then we’ll have a conversation about how much you owe.
waterbury-cpa.com/make-an-appointment/
FAQs
“Can the IRS take money I need for rent and groceries if I can’t pay how much I owe the IRS?”
By law, the IRS is not allowed to leave you destitute. If a bank levy or wage garnishment prevents you from paying for basic necessities (like housing, food, and utilities) it is considered economic hardship. As your specialist, I can force a human review of your case to prove that your actual cost of living is higher than the IRS’s national averages, effectively stopping aggressive collection actions.
“What happens if I can’t afford to pay how much I owe the IRS?”
If your income barely covers your living expenses, we can apply for Currently Not Collectible (CNC) status. This doesn’t wipe the debt away, but it puts a “freeze” on collections. The IRS must stop taking your wages or seizing your property as long as your financial situation doesn’t significantly improve.
“Will I be forced to sell my house or car if I can’t pay how much I owe the IRS?”
Rarely. The IRS calculates your Quick Sale Value, which is usually 80% of what your assets are worth. More importantly, they won’t force the sale of an asset if it creates a hardship or if the equity in that asset is needed to produce income. We work to show the IRS that your home or vehicle is a necessary asset for your family’s stability and your ability to keep working.
“What if the IRS Allowable Expenses are lower than my actual bills?”
The IRS uses national averages to decide what you should be spending on things like housing and health insurance. However, these averages often lag behind real-world inflation. I fight for legal exceptions to these caps. If we can document that your specific costs (like high medical bills or local rent) are necessary for your health and welfare, we can force the IRS to use your real numbers instead of their charts.
“Can I settle my tax debt for less than what I owe?”
Yes, through an Offer in Compromise (OIC) or a Partial Payment Installment Agreement (PPIA). If your Reasonable Collection Potential (what you can realistically pay before the IRS’s time to collect runs out) is less than your total debt, the law allows for a settlement. We essentially prove to the IRS that they will never collect the full amount, so it’s in their best interest to accept a smaller, finalized payment.